Genetically modified food and the least bad choice

It is easy to make a mistake when you have to choose between the lesser of two evils. Tony Blair made such a mistake as did George Bush when they decided to fight a war against Iraq. They chose the wrong course of action because they underestimated the bad consequences of the war and over estimated the dangers that would happen if they did not fight a war.Deciding upon the least bad course of action is so hard because people have prejudices which colour their judgement. I have never been able to come to a definitive view about genetically modified food. My prejudice leads me towards regarding the genetic manipulation of food plants as being unwholesome and having bad environmental consequences which can be impossible to foresee, given the complexity of the natural environment.

However, my knowledge tells me that farmers for years have been breeding the best blood lines in their animals and choosing the best crops and growing everything from apples to rice by selecting those strains which produce the greatest yields for the less work.

The genetic modifiers argue that it really not so bad if the genetic modification to our food is done in a laboratory rather than on the farm. They are partly right; modification by breeding is an extension of the process of natural selection, when over a period of time, foreshorten by the deliberate introduction of one strain or breed to another rather than the accidental meeting of them. The time scale is still natural in that generations come naturally and slowly enough to enable us to anticipate the consequences, even if we do not always do so,

Genetic modification on the scientific and industrial scale enables us, by a moment’s tinkering with the DNA of a life form in a laboratory to create at an instant a new plant or animal with known attributes. That new food form can be launched, grown, fattened and cropped to feed the mouths of an ever increasing human population. The instant nature of the process means that we cannot discover the significant consequences until it is too late. Those consequences may be the loss of a different species, the extinction of a life form, or the irretrievable change of a natural environment. Monster food will not create monster people but may perhaps kill off a species of rodent, insect or plant, or turn a swamp into a meadow or a meadow into a swamp.

The positives that genetically modified food can bring are much clearer than their disadvantages. They can feed the hungry in a world that is getting worrying full of people and in which more people are going hungry every year. The numbers of people on this planet – now approaching seven billions – are by their behaviour and practises changing the climate by releasing greenhouse gas emissions into he air. Those climate changes are creating droughts, particularly around the equator and irregular rainfall patterns around the tropics. As a result people who live in these regions are going hungry as they can no longer farm the land because the land can no long grow crops to support them.

Genetically modified food may save these lives, or some of them. It is therefore interesting that India has stopped its genetically modified vegetable food program. In 2009 Indian studies showed GM aubergines (egg plants) would be safe for those who eat them and for the environment. The Indian Environment Minsister Mr Jairam Ramesh has thought again and decided to halt the program to grow GM aubergines for the time being. He thinks it is better to be safe than sorry and needs more studies before he can be sure.

This decision was of course a difficult decision, trying to steer the least bad course through a complex sea where all the dangers have not been marked on the only chart available. A consequence may be that people will go hungry but perhaps, that may not be the worst consequence.

3 Responses

  1. The greater of the two evils mentioned in the start of my minutes here points towards the two evil leaders who are themselves being led by the very same people that own the GMO companies, oil industries, Who are altering and controlling the food that we eat, its not a problem if the food is modified genus to genus like most good horticuluralists have been doing for hundreds of years, Apple to apple, pear to pear to say, its when a totally different genus is introduced like a flounder to a tomato lets say just to make it last longer, if the food was grown and eaten locally like all food it would not go to waste.

    Then we come to the same scenario of waste and hungry, there are many wasted air and road miles which breeds discontent anongst the people because every mile an item of food has to travels someone else dies in its name, not because someone has run out of food but because someone has run out of money to buy it, normally countries of where it was grown in the first place being shipped around again to another only to return again at a much higher cost, thus fixing and control of the prices and amounts.

    The food basket of the planet is predominantly northern hemisphere where the bulk of the land lies with a few hot spots of supply in the southern regions, but we could still grow enough each year to feed everyone three times over if the global greedygram was curtailed, it all started with food mountains and subsidies and set aside to control the food and like fools we took the money resulting in what we have today, a triopoly of greed, seed, food and fruit of that seed being controlled by a single entity, taking us far away from the natural cycles, and it will be at our peril.

    If you study nature and watch her working she does it all with clockwork precission and at room temprature for free every day in the rain forest hardly anything ever goes hungry because it lives in a balances state from wind blown fruit to wild bore and fly to frog, everything is in symbiosis with everything else, within its it own climbs and climate.

    Mans climate changing policy is where everything goes wrong because he is only thinking of his own immediate enviornment based on money, money is not part of nature and until we realise this we will never make any headway and our greater enviornment will continue to suffer, here’ is a guy who can explain things a little finer for you.

  2. More about GM food and where it is going to.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: